Evil for Evil by James R. Benn

Evil for Evil is a bit of a twist on the classic war novel set during World War II in Jerusalem and Northern Ireland.

Billy Boyle is a Second Lt. on Dwight D. Eisenhower's staff and followed the war across Africa and Italy with Ike.  He has a distant familial relationship with Ike and calls him, affectionately, Uncle Ike.  His girl friend, Diana, is about to go out on another SOE special op for Britain behind enemy lines and Billy in a fit of frustration decides to take an assignment requested by the British to solve the disappearance of 50 Browning Automatic Rifles in Northern Ireland, which the British think may be linked to German infiltration and an attempt in the making of a German effort to topple the neutrality of the Irish Republic.

This sets Boyle up for a very interesting set of conflicting relationships in Ulster, for Irish-American Catholic Boyle is expected to take orders from the British and their Northern Irish Protestant cronies against possible members of the IRA, an organization Boyle and his family support fervently and with lots of dollars at home in Boston. 

The book is remarkable in how deftly Benn explains the complexities of Irish Catholic and Protestant interaction and politics and weaves it into the personalities, speech and actions of his characters.  In the end it is clear that the good and reasonable on both sides cooperate in the best interests of the whole, and the extremists on both sides tend to be more alike than different.  The extremists are killers with little real motive other than selfish self-interest. The only way to tell apart one their killings is by the MO.

If there had been more Boyles and more of the Protestant persuasion like DI Carrick, perhaps the bloody troubles in Northern Ireland would not have gone on for most of two centuries.

I found myself really being compelled to read on and on in this book with little desire to stop until I found out what would happen to Boyle and to the others who were looking for the guns, the German infiltrators and the extremists on both sides.  I will remember Billy and look forward to following him through the rest of the war in future Benn books.

This is a cracking good war mystery with a little bit of a twist and lots of action and surprises.

Liz Nichols